Can conscious hunting save the world?

Positive News

Whether we’re searching for food or love, we’re all hunters in some form – but it’s how we choose to fulfil that instinct that determines our fate and the lives of those around us, says Caspar Walsh who believes that by taking a life he saved his own

London is not a place you would associate with hunting, but growing up in the 70s, it was all around me, day and night. The threat of the hooded claw coming through my door kept me awake at night, right up to the point the door actually came in. Crime was how my father made a living and the consequences of that career choice meant our house was constantly under threat from raids from other criminals and the police.

I concluded that the world was a dangerous place, full of predators, out to get us. I cut myself off emotionally from a world I couldn’t trust and soon headed down the same destructive path as my father. I came within a hair’s breadth of a long-term prison sentence.

Slowly, over time, I emerged from drugs, alcohol and violence, onto a path of rehabilitation. This path led me to working with young men who were growing up in an identical environment to the one I had. Ours was a shared rite of passage. Not as ancient tradition would have it, but done in the absence of men we could trust to guide us from boyhood to adulthood, we initiated ourselves. And that was only ever going to end badly.

“We all hunt. For food, shelter, love. We have a choice. We can hunt with mindless violence and no regard for the sanctity of life or we can hunt with respect and dignity.”

My drug-, alcohol- and crime-free life was a far better one. It was an inspiration to the young men in prison we worked with. But I still couldn’t fully trust or connect to other humans. Nature had always been a place of escape and solace and this was where I retreated and where we took the young men we worked with. We walked, talked, sat round fires, shared stories and journals and poetry. We found connection and solace. But it still wasn’t enough. For each of us something was still broken and needed healing.

One summer I headed for the south Devon coast to camp with a group of friends who were foraging and hunting to eat and survive the week. On the second morning I headed down to the water with a friend’s spear-fishing outfit: wet suit, weight belt, fins and gun. Despite having been hunted all my life and in turn hunted others for what I needed, I had never actually hunted a living creature for food.

A few moments after entering the clear ocean, on the white sand floor beneath me, a creature appeared – in broad daylight – that should not have been there. The lobster beneath me was over two feet long. I was later told it was probably around 70 years old. I was filled with fear and trepidation. I pulled the trigger and the spear went through the animal. I felt distressed but was determined to give it a quick clean death. I brought it to the beach with a mixture of pride and shame, killed it cleanly and brought food to my friends.

In the coming weeks I noticed something was changing in me. I continued to hunt for fish. Continued to feel the same conflict in taking an animal’s life. I would only eat animals if I was prepared to hunt them and to do this with the utmost respect. What was changing in me was unexpected: a deeper feeling of connection to other humans, to animals, to the planet. I was discovering the meaning of a word I had heard many times but had always been left puzzled by: empathy. This was a rite of passage I could pass down.

Like what you’re reading? Get your Positive News subscription here

The group of young men we took to East Prawle had that morning been in their prison cells. It had taken a little time for them to acclimatise to the beauty of the beach. We gave them each a fishing rod and they bounced down to the shoreline. They took to it like they had been doing it all their lives.

A young lad soon caught a small fish. He brought it back proudly to the fire and held it up. He was keen to kill it. We said if he was going to do this with us, it would have to be clean, quick and respectful. He would then have to cook and eat it. There was a pause, in that moment his face changed from blood lust, to deep thinking, followed by recognition. He killed the fish, cooked and ate in pensive silence.

Later that day he came to us and said something ‘massive had happened’ for him in the moment he took the fish’s life. For the first time in his life, he felt empathy for the victims of his crimes. Empathy and compassion. His recognition was a lot quicker than mine. In the coming years, this experience with the young men we brought to the ocean to fish repeated itself over and over.

Hunting for me is an ancient rite of passage that has been central to communities across the planet for millennia. In the west, it has largely been lost. In the absence of a community they can trust, young men are initiating themselves. This is dangerous, often lethal territory. I have worked with many young men imprisoned for gang violence. These crimes have been committed by human beings who feel themselves on the margins of society and life. They believe they have nothing to lose. They know that something dramatic and life changing is meant to happen to them at this point in their life – it is in their DNA; their ancestral memory.

“I was discovering the meaning of a word I had heard many times but had always been left puzzled by: empathy.”

You do not have to kill animals to understand the transformational power of conscious hunting. The young people we work with also take part in archery. This involves targets and animal replicas.

Although slower than taking an animal’s life, the same realisation and transformation takes place. The same recognition and transition from ‘I’ to ‘we’. We see it time and time again.

We all hunt. For food, shelter, love. We have a choice. We can hunt with mindless violence and no regard for the sanctity of life or we can hunt with respect and dignity, taking only what we need. We will all be food for something when our time is up. This is essential knowledge and connects us to the cycle of life; gives us a respect and understanding for nature that goes beyond a scenic vista.

Understanding this connects us to ourselves, to each other and to the wider, planetary ecosystem.

More and more young men are signing up to wars and causes they don’t fully understand because they are looking for belonging, for a tribe. Understanding the human hunting drive in every possible form, internal, external, predatory and conscious is key to changing this catastrophic life path. By connecting to nature, by understanding the place of hunting in our lives we understand more who we are, what makes us tick and what place we have in the world.

Look to those in your communities who need you. The young people you pass or cross the street to avoid. That wild, un-tempered energy you see is searching, hunting for focus, direction and healthy nourishment from life. This is something every single member of society must take part in, one way or another. Only you know what part it is that you play in the support of these young people.

We are hunters to the core, always have been, always will be. We need a 3D awareness of the place of conscious, sacred hunting in society and bring it back into the centre, to how we eat, work, treat ourselves, each other and interact with the natural world. Conscious hunting gives us a clear route to saving the planet from the current path it is heading down. We are wild to the core and this wildness, disciplined, channelled and acknowledged, can be a force for creative, collective, global transformation.

Caspar Walsh spoke on Friday 9 October – at at TEDxTotnes.

Photo title: Caspar Walsh's work includes teaching young men archery to try reconnecting them with themselves and the natural world

Photo credit: © Caspar Walsh

  • Matthew Boyle

    Are Mr. Walsh and his band of Merry Men consciously hunting or consciously hurting? Maybe it was just a typo. Personally, I think this so-called conscious hunting is best left to the indigenous tribes of the world who truly need to do it to survive. Meanwhile, the rest of us better be careful not to deceive ourselves.

    In this particular article, the author seems to advocate killing other sentient creatures of our Earth as a means for us to undergo a “transformation” or “discover empathy.” Does that strike anyone else as oxymoronic?

    He also writes that doing this can “save the world”?! What a presumptuous title! He should be an ad-man for a bow and arrow company, not a self-styled guru.

    On the one hand, maybe it is a viable way to start rehabilitating young people who have grown up surrounded by violence. They are diverted from hurting or being hurt by humans, to hurting animals and “reconnecting with nature.” In that context, maybe it has a limited application. But that leads me to wonder if Mr. Walsh has a next step in mind, or will the participants continue to depend on ending the lives of animals to keep themselves transformed and empathetic? If the latter is the case, when will their transformation be complete? The animals and I want to know a.s.a.p.!

    On the other hand, the author may simply be repackaging an irrelevant method of survival, using new age lingo, to clothe what is basically unnecessary killing and a hobby rolled into one. He hopes his ideas will then be at least easier to swallow than a piece of 70-year-old lobster.

  • Charlotte Moncrieff

    What a pretentious article , why is it in positive news ? There is nothing positive about killing innocent creatures. I would be deeply ashamed to have killed an ancient sea creature. This man is an arrogant twerp proposing violent behaviour be cured by violence towards smaller helpless creatures . Would he like to be shot with a harpoon or crossbow to enable someone larger than he to find themselves and thereby save the world?

  • Mr. Ross

    It’s a fine thing indeed to hear of another man talk of the wildness in men and boys, and the need for proper training and initiation.

    We need boys to be well mentored by mature men who have thoroughly integrated their wildness. This process of maturation sees a man becoming far more loving and empathic, just as he actualizes the wild aspects of his being. When this process is guided by a mature elder, we see what positive masculinity can be…something deeply connected to all life, powerful, capable, empathic and containing the nobility and courage that we would all love to manifest as men…and in fact that women long for in us to.

    Thanks to Positive News for publishing something so positive about men….

  • Elliot

    I am also bewildered as to why this is on Positive News. So he’s killing things when he doesn’t need to. That’s not a good thing. If he’d become vegetarian or vegan, i might have respected him but this is out of order and an example of the selfishness of some humans (like Mr Ross there).
    In fact, in response to him, your concept of masculinity is antiquated. There is no honour in killing something with a weapon or with your bare hands. Your comments are very sexist and very much out of date.
    I request that this article is removed and nothing like it will be published on here again.

  • Rowan

    A very interesting article, well done for publishing it. I would agree that there is value in this idea, and not just for young men. We have lost the rites of passage for young people and this is one way of reclaiming them. To deliberately cause the death of a fellow being is a serious matter: all indigenous cultures know this. Hunting in order to live is therefore always done respectfully, honouring the spirit of the animal, thanking it for the gift of its life. When indigenous people are driven from their land and denied their culture, they fall into despair – for many reasons, not the least of which is that they cannot go out on the land and hunt. In our western culture we raise animals in cruel conditions, slaughter them without respect, package their flesh in plastic and display it in neat, bloodless lumps so that we can pretend we have nothing to do with their deaths. Vegetarians collude in the cruel treatment of cows and hens; vegans ignore the millions of rats and mice poisoned in grainstores. I say this not to cast blame but to point out that we humans kill in order to live, whoever we are, whatever our ethics. If you would have a clean soul, grow your own food, buy organic, hunt with respect and honour all the deaths that have enabled you to live.

  • Ragini

    I am bewildered by some of the comments here – questioning about why this article is in positive news.
    This is a GREAT article and I applaud the writer for sharing his experience – I do not see anything cruel about what he is proposing – we are all animals part of the food chain and humans being close to the top will hunt – doing so in a conscious manner (as opposed to the overly cruel and wasteful manner in which we rear and slaughter animals to provide more food than we know what to do with) and using nature to reconnect with our true selves is a great avenue for transforming the tragedies of our human existence – Well done Caspar for not only sharing your story but also using your tragedy to help other men – your work is so needed.

  • John McDonald

    This is by far the most psychopathic article I’ve ever seen on Positive News. The only real men are those who do not hurt, maim or kill.

  • David Bird

    Well done PN for being brave and taking a risk, writing about a more controversial topic that some people may automatically close their minds to.

  • ccmoncrieff

    Thank you John McDonald, other than you the men who have made laudatory comments are talking BS . The author said he moved away from violence towards..more violence, quite incomprehensible.

  • Newman Yort

    Thanks for showing me the positive news side of inflicting pain and cruelty in order to be “connected to the cycle of life”. I am already feeling better about myself, which is the ultimate goal in all I do. I would write more but I have to find a woman to hit over the head so I can drag her back to my cave.

  • Newman Yort

    yes, i agree, your comment is quite incomprehensible..

  • Chris

    Well done PN for posting this article. I don’t understand where all the negativity comes from. These young men are being taught to think about their relationship to the world around them. How their actions affect the animal kingdom & the planet they live on. If more people in general went on these trips, maybe the world wouldn’t be in such a bad place. Maybe we wouldn’t cut down rain forests just to grow palm oil so big food corporations can produce unnatural food that gives people all manner of illnesses. Maybe the supermarkets wouldn’t throw away millions of tonnes of food every year whilst thousands of children go hungry. At least these young men cleanly kill the fish they catch & eat all of it. Do you know how the animal you eat was killed?

  • Pingback: Osbert Lancaster()

Start typing and press Enter to search

Pin It on Pinterest